Local power utility makes no sense | Letter to the editor

To the editor:

Mr. Tom Goodwin’s letter published on Dec. 16 unfortunately contains both misinformation and disinformation.

He posits that creating a Bainbridge Island Power utility would free us from polluting power sources. Not so. By switching from PSE to BPA we would only pay for allegedly pollution free hydro power, which is anything but pollution free.

The reservoirs are unfortunately major producers of methane gas due to decomposing biomass which water sources flush into them. Then the idea that switching to hydro power would necessarily be cheap and effective is disingenuous.

Nearly half of Pacific Northwest community power utilities charge more than PSE. Even though a 50 MW block of power would be available, Bainbridge Island used 86 MW last winter.

BPA could accommodate us, though we might be using nuclear generated power which provides 9 percent of BPA’s power.

Still, coal-fired power plants would continue to be required and the PNW’s pollution problems would not be affected meaningfully.

Fortunately, the Colstrip, Montana power plant will be closing two of its four units in 2022 and Washington’s only coal fired plant in Centralia is scheduled to close in 2025. They will need to be replaced by natural gas plants as there is nothing else technically capable of generating that amount of power in the near term.

On top of that, BPA power would co-mingle with PSE power in transmission so we may just wind up with coal-sourced electricity no matter what.

As for Microsoft, they have claimed to be powered by 100 percent renewable energy since 2014, but there’s more to the story. Their two major wind power purchases are in Texas and Illinois, to power their nearby data centers. They also purchase Renewable Energy Certificates to cover their other expenditures, but we don’t know where that power is generated and who uses it. So while it sounds nice in a publicity statement, the net effect for PNW pollution is a resounding zero. Misinformation and disinformation. Judging by the experiences of Jefferson County, instituting a Bainbridge Island Power utility would be more expensive than current costs and would do absolutely nothing to address PNW pollution.

Finally, with the city’s record of utility performance, why would anyone trust them with this infinitely larger responsibility?

VARON MULLIS

Bainbridge Island

More in Letters to the Editor

Let justice be done, starting in the House | Letter to the editor

To the editor: I am writing to publicly thank Representative Derek Kilmer… Continue reading

Many reasons for opposition to hotel | Letter to the editor

To the editor: Regarding the proposed land use for the 80-plus-room hotel… Continue reading

Medicare for All is politically popular | Letter to the editor

To the editor: Medicare for All is overdue. While the current political… Continue reading

Plea for H-E-L-P from the Tweeter-in-Chief | Letter to the editor

To the editor: Like many others, when I first heard the tweet… Continue reading

Thank you Bainbridge for your great support | Letter to the editor

To the editor: On behalf of Housing Resources Bainbridge, we would like… Continue reading

Squeaky Wheels had more to say in letter | Letter to the editor

To the editor: The Review article on “Bainbridge council votes to seek… Continue reading

Sending them out through the ‘in’ door | Letter to the editor

To the editor: Trump doesn’t see people of color as Americans. He… Continue reading

Elizabeth Warren has it right on health care | Letter to the editor

To the editor: I was surprised to see the a lengthy takedown… Continue reading

Court martial could end our nightmare | Letter to the editor

To the editor: We didn’t need Trump’s tweet telling congresswomen of color… Continue reading

WSF should do more to help senior riders | Letter to the editor

To the editor: I spend about one-third of the year on Bainbridge.… Continue reading

Pledge for no road signs | Letter to the editor

I’m currently serving as a Bainbridge Island city councilmember and mayor, having… Continue reading

Federal tax credit is needed for renters | Letter to the editor

To the editor: I appreciated the letter from Sharon Gilpin “Housing crisis… Continue reading