Gese takes reins of Sheriff’s Office

New leader focusing on implementing new police reforms, hiring

  • Thursday, September 23, 2021 10:50am
  • News

For six years, John Gese held the No. 2 spot at the Kitsap County sheriff’s office, but after being sworn in Aug. 30, he moved into the top post — becoming sheriff.

The 30-year law enforcement veteran and Seattle native who has spent his entire career at the sheriff’s office now controls the purse strings of the office’s $43 million budget and is responsible for a staff of more than 250 people.

As he settles into his new position, Kitsap News Group interviewed the sheriff about his new job. Gese said priorities for his first year include adjusting to police reforms laid out by lawmakers and sought by members of the community, and filling staff vacancies.

New ways of policing

“We are very sensitive about things that happened with the George Floyd death and all the resulting calls for social justice reform, criminal justice reform. Even here, we saw protests. That had an impact on us. It caused us to stop and rethink how we are doing things and make sure we want to do things in the proper and fair and just way,” Gese said.

Several police reform laws were recently enacted by the state Legislature. New rules on the use of force, limits on when law enforcement can engage in a vehicle pursuit, and the ability to decertify a police office are some examples. “We are trying to adapt to the reforms and incorporate [them] into our training, policies and culture,” he said.

That is easier said than done. “It’s been a challenge to keep up with all the new laws and make sure we understand the interpretation of them,” he said. “So, there is a lot of work going on right now. A lot of analysis of how we do business.”

What now constitutes lawful use of force and when it can be used in a variety of situations is an area of concern. “We don’t fully understand or know some of the parameters [of when the use of force is permissible]. We are in the same boat as a lot of other agencies and trying to work with the legislature and attorney general’s office and our own local legislatures to fully understand what the boundaries are in these new laws.”

Prior use of force laws had been the subject of numerous court cases. Decisions from those cases helped interpret the rules, providing law enforcement with guidance as to what constituted lawful police force. The new rules have yet to undergo court review, leaving law enforcement without direction, he said. “It’s tough for our officers on the street. They want to do the right thing. They don’t want to get in trouble or get charged with a crime. Right now, I think is a feeling-out period. I think we are being slow and cautious.”

Staffing shortfall

Drive through any business district and you are likely to see a string of “Help Wanted” signs in store windows. It is no different at the sheriff’s office. There are 25 unfilled positions in the office, which includes deputies, corrections officers and support staff, Gese noted. “We have been running about a 10% vacancy rate. That’s tough because we have a growing community. The more pressure you have on [staff], unfortunately, the chances of them not staying … gets to be more of an issue.”

The drain has largely involved veteran staff eligible to retire. “We have a lot of people who have reached that 20-, 25- or 30-year mark who are retiring out of our ranks, and that has accelerated at a little bit with all the stuff that’s been going on. Among tenured folks, some of them feel, ‘I think this is a good time to leave.’ But that is something that we expected, looking at the demographics,” he said.

Gese noted his agency is not seeing newer deputies depart. The department has been hiring a number of officers from other locations who want to work in Kitsap County, he said. Recruiting efforts have been hampered by COVID-19. Normally, the office would go to job fairs and schools to seek applications, but those avenues were shut down due to COVID restrictions.

Once recruiting gears up, Gese said he aims to improve diversity on the force. The office is reaching out to minority faith-based leaders and other prominent minority leaders to promote a wider variety of candidates, he said.

Uneasy promotion

Gese’s journey to becoming the new sheriff was not without issue. Retiring Sheriff Gary Simpson was a Democrat, so Kitsap County Democratic Precinct Committee officers were responsible for pre-screening potential replacements. They then were to make a recommendation to the county commissioners.

Simpson endorsed Gese as his replacement. But Democratic party officers recommended Sgt. Brandon Myers. In the end, the three Kitsap County commissioners selected Gese.

Gese will serve as sheriff for the remaining year and a half of Simpson’s term before an election will take place.


Gese joined the sheriff’s office in 1991, first as a patrol deputy, then a traffic deputy. In 1999, he was promoted to sergeant and worked in internal affairs. After becoming a lieutenant in 2004, he was promoted to chief of patrol. In 2015, he was appointed undersheriff where he worked closely with Simpson for six years and until he was appointed sheriff.

The sheriff attended Western Washington University in Bellingham. On his way to earning a degree in sociology, Gese was torn between becoming a social worker or a police officer. “It appealed to me that there was a variety to police work, and you would have contact with all sorts of people.”

While a number of issues confront the sheriff’s office, Gese points out that citizens largely support his office.

“We are lucky by the fact that we are more connected to the community… I like to think that is because of the reputation that we have built. So, my goal is to not violate that trust and maintain that reputation.”


More in News

BI wants ferry service restored

Bainbridge Island wants its ferry system back. The city is sending a… Continue reading

Halloween events in BI

Four Halloween events are taking place on Bainbridge Island as the spooky… Continue reading

The current skate park is for those with advanced abilities. File Photo
BI park prepares for major remodel

Also, COVID vax for all parks users?

The Bainbridge Island City Council will have a public meeting to decide on improvements on Eagle Harbor Drive. This idea was shot down because of how crowded it would be with cyclists and walkers on the same side going in different directions.
Environment not as important on this project

Safety concerns override that on Eagle Harbor plan

It’s a gamble not getting COVID vaccine

Many people still are not get vaccinated to protect themselves and others… Continue reading

Eldon Van Liere stands next to his late wife's painting of Luxembourg Gardens in Paris, where they often traveled together. Tyler Shuey/Bainbridge Island Review
BI artist’s work lives on after her passing

Bainbridge Island artist Elizabeth Van Liere passed away in 2020 and some… Continue reading

The author of this book will be in Bainbridge. Courtesy Photo
Bainbridge Island briefs

Protest exhibit The Bainbridge Island Historical Museum is opening a new exhibit… Continue reading

Roundabouts on Highway 305 divided the Bainbridge Island City Council candidates at a recent debate. Courtesy Illustration
LWV’s debate features rapid-fire answers

Compared with two earlier debates last week, Bainbridge Island City Council candidates… Continue reading

Most Read