At Risk: The Idea of America | Mel Gurtov

Perhaps the most damaging legacy of the Trump years is the disservice he and his associates are doing to Americans’ sense of self and nation.

In ordinary times there would not be much debate about what it means to be an American or what are American values.

Every school child learns these things: It’s Civics 1. Race, class, and gender identity have always been important, but generally they have been subsumed under a larger identification with the nation. “We’re all Americans, we all share the dream, we live in a land of opportunity.”

But under Trump identity politics has come to the fore, pushing aside the tenets of liberal democracy and respect for diversity, and replacing them with right-wing white nationalism framed by a (false) populist (i.e., anti-establishment) political agenda, a narrowing of opportunity, and mean-spirited discourse.

Liberal intellectuals uniformly denounce that agenda but they differ among themselves, as the latest issue of Foreign Affairs shows, about whether or not racial, class, and other identities promote or undermine national unity. Those identities are critical to maintain in the face of unequal treatment, yet the (liberal) nationalists fear they will undermine a focus on repurposing America.

A related debate is evidently taking place at the state level. In Michigan we learn that public school educators are arguing over whether curricula should describe the American form of government as a republic or a democracy, with implications for how civil society and social equality are taught. These debates reveal just how uncertain the idea of America still is.

So long as these debates persist, America will have no special claim to being an enlightened example to the world. Instead, America will remain divided, consumed by antagonisms between races, classes, and gender, and by contending nationalisms, rather than propelled by demonstrating how a pluralistic society is able, through consensus politics and democratic choice, to surmount differences. Chalk up these painful debates to Trump’s intentionally divisive way of governing, which he relied on to get to the White House and is relying on again to stay there.

The closer we get to November 2020, the more vindictive, threatening, and desperate Donald Trump will become.

Witness, for instance, not just his preparedness to use illegal means of stemming immigration, but also his more frequent accusations of “treason” against anyone who defies him.

Bottom line for me: The Democrats need a candidate who, like Obama in 2012, will speak passionately on behalf of national unity as well as on the virtues of diversity and the restoration of democratic rule.

Mel Gurtov, syndicated by PeaceVoice, is Professor Emeritus of Political Science at Portland State University.

More in News

Bainbridge teen, Poulsbo woman injured in Highway 305 crash

A Bainbridge Island teen and a Poulsbo woman were injured in a… Continue reading

Opposition to hotel continues as project heads to planning commission

Opponents of a new hotel in downtown Winslow have three suggestions. Build… Continue reading

St. Cecilia sails to Seattle Aquarium field trip

Saint Cecilia Catholic School students in kindergarten through eighth grade, as well… Continue reading

Farewell party planned for BHS 100 Building

The Bainbridge community is invited to walk the halls of the Bainbridge… Continue reading

All fizzle no sizzle: Annual July Fourth fireworks show set to be absent from this year’s festivities

This year’s Fourth of July festivities on Bainbridge Island will go silently… Continue reading

Weekend weather report: Sunny in the seventies | The Bainbridge Blab

Good days, sunshine. That’s the latest weekend weather forecast for Bainbridge Island… Continue reading

Bainbridge and Eagle Harbor High School graduation set for Saturday

The annual joint Bainbridge and Eagle Harbor high school graduation ceremony is… Continue reading

Hilst awarded Fulbright Fellowship

Noel Hilst, a 2015 graduate of Bainbridge High School, has been awarded… Continue reading

Driver in fatal Father’s Day crash won’t face charges

The Bainbridge teen who was behind the wheel in a deadly car… Continue reading

Most Read