Seahawks Jacob Hollister falls across the goal line for the game winning touchdown against Buccaneers Jordan Whitehead in overtime Sunday afternoon at CenturyLink Field in Seattle on November 3, 2019.(Kevin Clark | The Herald)

Seahawks Jacob Hollister falls across the goal line for the game winning touchdown against Buccaneers Jordan Whitehead in overtime Sunday afternoon at CenturyLink Field in Seattle on November 3, 2019.(Kevin Clark | The Herald)

Grading the Seahawks’ 40-34 win over the Buccaneers | Nick Patterson

Here’s how the Seahawks grade out in their 40-34 overtime victory over the Tampa Buccaneers on Sunday at CenturyLink Field:


Russell Wilson covers up so many ills. Seattle’s quarterback gave his MVP campaign another shot in the arm by throwing for 378 yards and five touchdowns, including engineering a drive in 46 seconds that should have won the game at the end of regulation, then ensuring Tampa Bay had no shot in OT by marching right down the field and into the end zone in the extra period. Wilson’s connection with Tyler Lockett (13 catches, 152 yards, two TDs) has reached the inhuman level, and rookie DK Metcalf (six catches 123 yards, one TD) is emerging as a star. Running back Chris Carson had another 100-yard rushing effort, though most of those yards came on one play, and the team has to be concerned that he lost another fumble.

Grade: A-


This was not Seattle’s defense’s best day. It started from the beginning, when the Seahawks allowed the Buccaneers to race right down the field for a touchdown on the game’s opening drive. The Seahawks couldn’t generate a pass rush on Tampa Bay quarterback Jameis Winston, despite blitzing constantly, and Winston and receiver Mike Evans had a field day. Seattle had just one takeaway against an offense that turned the ball over 11 times over the previous two games, and that came when Winston had the ball slip out of his hands. And only needing to prevent a touchdown in the final minutes, the defense couldn’t even do that.

Grade: D


Oh, Jason Myers. Seattle’s kicker had a disastrous performance, missing a 47-yard field goal and doinking an extra-point attempt off the upright in the second quarter, then missing wide right on a 40-yarder that would have won the game as time expired in the fourth quarter. Indeed, special teams could have cost Seattle the game at the end of the first half when the combination of Myers’ missed extra point and a long kickoff return nearly gifted Tampa Bay a field goal. The one saving grace was punter Michael Dickson booming all three of his punts.

Grade: D


There were good moments of recognition by Seattle’s coaches. When they saw a four-man pass rush was ineffective, they dialed up the blitz, so at least they were trying even if it wasn’t effective. Late in the game they targeted Bucs rookie cornerback Jamel Dean, who was abused by Metcalf both for the 53-yard go-ahead touchdown in the fourth quarter, as well as key plays in overtime. However, Pete Carroll just can’t resist throwing the challenge flag looking for a pass interference reversal, even though it’s clear the replay officials don’t want to overturn calls. This time it cost Seattle a timeout that could have been useful at the end of the fourth quarter.

Grade: B


The good news is the Seahawks once again showed they can overcome adversity, coming back from a 14-point first-half deficit and not being thrown for a loop by everything that went wrong at the end of regulation. The bad news is the degree of difficulty gets a whole lot harder starting now, as Seattle’s final seven games are against teams with a combined record of 40-18-1. Wilson is good enough to overcome other misfiring aspects of the team when playing against the likes of Tampa Bay and Atlanta. But the Seahawks can’t count on him alone when they face the undefeated San Francisco 49ers next Monday.

Grade: C+

More in Sports

A lost season: WIAA declares spring sports season won’t happen

The spring sports season is officially over — earlier and emptier than… Continue reading

Spartan gridiron star signs to play with Lewis and Clark

Bainbridge High School senior Sio Peato recently signed a letter of intent… Continue reading

Sole State Spartan wrestler grapples through two showings

Bainbridge High Schooler Garrett Swanson, the only member of the school’s varsity… Continue reading

Spartans claim second place at state swim meet

Spartan swimmer Jude Wenker found himself in a familiar place on Saturday… Continue reading

Annual cycling season kickoff returns to island streets | Photo gallery

Once more the last Sunday in February heralded the unofficial start of… Continue reading

Spartans send two gymnasts to State

Two gymnasts from the Bainbridge Spartan squad have qualified for this week’s… Continue reading

Spartans swim to second at Districts

Jude Wenker placed first in the 200-yard freestyle and also won the… Continue reading

Juanita loss knocks Spartans from SeaKing tourney

A first-game loss to Juanita Feb. 15 ended the postseason run of… Continue reading

Island girls score initial win in postseason showing

So far, so good. The Bainbridge High School varsity girls basketball team… Continue reading

Chilly Hilly bike ride to return to island roads

Bainbridge drivers and ferry travelers should be on the lookout for boatloads… Continue reading

Spartans make mark in Metro League Championships

Four gymnasts from Bainbridge Island had top-10 finishes at the Metro League… Continue reading

Boys b-ball postseason ends with loss to Roosevelt

After a victorious first appearance in the postseason, a loss to Roosevelt… Continue reading