The Pro-Life case for the COVID vaccines

  • Saturday, March 20, 2021 1:30am
  • Opinion

I’m pretty open about my pro-life views. I want abortion criminalized, banned and recognized as an act of inhumanity. I agree with Mother Theresa that “abortion has become the greatest destroyer of peace, because it destroys two lives, the life of the child and the conscience of the mother.”

I am also a Catholic, and I am quite proud that my church is the most vocal, most unapologetically pro-life among the three great monotheistic traditions. I know there are some Catholics who disagree with the church’s position on abortion, including President Biden, but that’s their burden. They can deal with God when the time comes, and they are called to explain that moral compromise.

While we can never impose Catholic morality on secular law, we do need to follow its guidance in our personal choices. And one of those choices is whether to be vaccinated against the coronavirus.

I got my first shot this week. It was the Moderna vaccine, which gave me some relief. The reason for that relief is the main point of this column.

The Moderna and Pfizer vaccines, two of the three that have been cleared for use in the United States, were tested on cells derived from aborted babies.

Those cell lines have been cloned and reproduced, and date back to the 1970s and 1980s. Those two vaccines have some remote, generations-removed connection to elective abortions, but the vaccines themselves are so distant from the act itself that they cannot really be viewed as morally compromised. Not so with the third vaccine, produced by Johnson & Johnson, which used abortion-derived cells in the direct production of the vaccine.

This is where the dilemma arises, for those of us who call ourselves pro-life.

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops has come out with guidance that essentially tells the faithful that while some of the vaccines are morally compromised, it is better to be vaccinated than not to be. Choices can be made, and in some cases people can opt to wait for the vaccine they feel has less of a connection to abortion, but ultimately the church says the evil of the pandemic outweighs the temporal evil of using the products of abortion.

The Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith stated last December that “it is morally acceptable to receive COVID-19 vaccines that have used cell lines from aborted fetuses in their research and production process.” That principle was echoed by the Vatican COVID-19 commission that stated that “all clinically recommended vaccinations can be used with a clear conscience.”

As if to punctuate the point, both Popes Francis and Benedict have been vaccinated.

Of course, people have differences of opinion. Many local dioceses are urging people to avoid the Johnson & Johnson vaccine if they can. And many have said that they will not take the any vaccine that is connected, even remotely, to dead babies.

I know that some of my pro-life friends will be skeptical of my personal choice of Moderna, given a vocal history of opposing anything that seems-in even the most minuscule way-to advance the “choice” agenda.

I sympathize with them much more than they suspect. That shot in my upper arm did not fill me with euphoria and relief, as many have described themselves in the moments after being vaccinated. It filled me with resignation, and a sense that I was doing something to keep my family safe. It also brought with it the sense of shame that this “safety” came at the expense of lost lives.

Those who don’t see abortion as the greatest modern evil will laugh at that feeling, I suppose. They don’t understand the horrible implications of benefiting from the death of innocents. They would probably understand it if I said “I don’t want to use any drug that was developed from Nazi-era experiments or the Tuskegee syphilis trials.” But mention abortion, and their eyes glaze over.

They’re irrelevant to me. And at the risk of justifying myself to God, I like to think that those innocent souls that were sacrificed in the 1970s and 1980s have been raised up, glorified and sanctified by their ability to save future generations from this scourge.

I carry in me their sacrifice and their legacy. That the church understands this as well is a singular blessing. And a painful one.

Christine Flowers is an attorney and a columnist for the Delaware County Daily Times and can be reached at

More in Opinion

Debunking the accuracy of the word ‘debunked’

Did I ever tell you about my late Uncle Vernon and the… Continue reading

Defending the Karens of the social media world

As parents of three teenage daughters, my wife and I expend a… Continue reading

Baseball strikes out on politics

You can’t escape politics anywhere now - not even in America’s once… Continue reading

Voters say yes to Biden’s infrastructure plan

Here’s a quiz for the Republican politicians among you. Check as many… Continue reading

Beware of a federal bailout of states

A year after the first COVID-19 shutdown, President Biden signed the American… Continue reading

Teachers betray local students, favor immigrants

Under the guise of the “This is not who we are. America… Continue reading

Georgia voting law is no return to Jim Crow

I am so glad the whole white supremacy and gun nut narrative… Continue reading

May I sing the Housing Subdivision Blues?

My wife and I would never have met, except that her family… Continue reading

This time Infrastructure Week is for real

What welcome words these were, from a newly elected president: “We’re going… Continue reading

Most Read