Bainbridge: new hotbed of Eymanism?

  • Wednesday, July 11, 2007 9:00am
  • Opinion

They are ruining our community.

They can’t be trusted with our money.

They should put it all to a public vote.

Funny times are these, when the rhetoric flying around liberal Bainbridge Island sounds remarkably like that coming out of the Tim Eyman camp. But scattered calls for a vote on the Winslow Tomorrow downtown planning initiative have carried a timbre ironically like that of the anti-tax crusader’s permanently offensive peel.

Eyman resurfaced in the news columns this week, turning in a bushel of signatures to put his latest anti-tax measure on the November ballot. If passed, I-960 would require a two-thirds vote of the Legislature for any state tax increase, and legislative approval of any fee increase by state agencies (which now have general discretion to set their own fees, within certain limitations).

Any state tax increase also would be placed on the ballot for a public advisory vote.

Closer to home, some islanders wary of a changing downtown have demanded that aspects of Winslow Tomorrow – from proposed building height increases, to the whole kit and caboodle – be put on a ballot for islanders to decide. Amongst the reasons cited: downtown improvements will cost too much, and those making the decisions are agenda-driven, too out of touch with the desires of ordinary citizens.

Leaving the merits of I-960 and Winlsow Tomorrow to another discussion, there is a commonality in the themes used by supporters of one and opponents of the other. Fear of higher taxes is one; an innate distrust of representative democracy and elected officials – the remote and unresponsive “they” of so much rhetoric – is another, and far more pernicious. And the supposed solution to our civic woes? More “direct democracy,” giving the people more votes on more issues.

Which raises an obvious question: why even have a Legislature, or for that matter a City Council, if not to make tough decisions? We’ve said this before, and we’ll repeat it here: if representative democracy doesn’t work at the local level, where does it work? Either we have faith in our island representatives – elected by us, from among us – to find consensus on complex issues like downtown planning, or we don’t. We should.

It’s unclear whether anyone on the council is considering a referendum on any or all of Winslow Tomorrow.

We tend to think that its most controversial aspects, namely downtown building heights, will be scaled back a bit, blunting much of the opposition through the very deliberative process in which some islanders have so little faith.

Indeed, the best way to shape our future is really through this fall’s elections, in which four of seven City Council seats are up for grabs; the candidates’ views on Winslow Tomorrow can be pivotal.

It would be a Bainbridge quirk to oppose Eyman’s initiative to refer every tax increase to Washington voters, and with our next breath demand a public vote on Winslow Tomorrow.

Better to ask the right questions of our candidates, cast our votes come November, and let real American democracy – the representative kind – take its course.



• The Bainbridge Island Arts and Humanities Council has not yet officially undertaken sponsorship of the “Bainbridge in the Seventies” documentary project (Editorial, July 4), so interested contributors should contact Kathleen Thorne directly at 842.0985 or

More in Opinion

Protest or riot? It depends where you stand

When the Nazis wanted to march through Skokie, Ill., many of the… Continue reading

Don’t waste opportunity for police reform

With tthe conviction of former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, America once… Continue reading

Fake vaccine cards and American selfishness

Republican pollster Frank Luntz met last weekend with 17 vaccine-resisting Trump voters… Continue reading

Political correctness is going to kill comedy

As graduation looms, my son Gideon has been named both salutatorian and… Continue reading

A hunger for normalcy

My recent trip to Florida was glorious for one simple reason: it… Continue reading

Calls for justice after police kill another teen

With the eyes of the nation on Minnesota with the twin dramas… Continue reading

Can we possibly laugh about seasonal allergies?

Tree huggers, are you contemplating a Zoom meeting with Mr. Elm instead?… Continue reading

Some Christians have forgotten moral duty

I don’t want to malign anyone’s religious faith. I really don’t. But… Continue reading

Biden’s Supreme Court Commission about 1 thing

Disregard the policy, the law school lecture language, the obfuscation and don’t… Continue reading

Most Read