Democratic-controlled House passes clean fuels bill despite bipartisan opposition | 2020 Legislative Session

OLYMPIA – People will be asked to use a lot less gasoline and to convert to alternative clean fuels in the next 15 years if a proposal before the Legislature becomes law.

After lengthy debate, Engrossed Second Substitute House Bill 1110 passed 54-44 in the House despite bipartisan opposition. Five Democratic lawmakers voted no.

If it becomes law, the measure would direct the Department of Ecology to adopt a clean fuels program with the goal of limiting greenhouse gas emissions per unit of fuel to 20 percent of 2017 levels by the year 2035.

Clean fuel advocates believe the policy could reduce emissions and pollution and give incentives for the innovation and adoption of new clean and renewable fuels to be used within the state. Opponents worry the proposed law would increase energy costs for consumers and businesses.

Rep. Mike Chapman, D-Port Angeles, said Renewable Energy Group produces 100 million gallons of renewable biodiesel in his district. He said 90 percent of that fuel is sold out-of-state.

Chapman added that promising economic potential exists in the use of lumber and logging waste for biofuel production.

He said the bill is about, “a lot more than protecting the environment. This is a bill about jobs.”

However, many were concerned that the legislation would lead to an increase in gas prices, causing disproportionate economic burden to rural and agricultural communities.

A report that analyzed transportation fuels in the Puget Sound Region estimated a 22 cent to 57 cent increase in cost per gallon of gas by 2030 under a clean fuel standard similar to what is proposed by this legislation. The report estimated a 24 cent to 63 cent per gallon increase for diesel for the same timeframe.

Rep. Alex Ybarra, R-Quincy, urged his colleagues to vote no on the bill, testifying that people in his district have to drive long distances on a daily basis. He said people may have to drive more than 30 miles one-way just to commute to work, buy groceries or even to attend school.

Rep. Tom Dent, R-Moses Lake, said on his ranch, fuel is the second largest expense behind fertilizer. He said an increase in fuel cost would also cause the price of fertilizer to rise. He argued many ranchers would not be able to afford this kind of increase in expenditures.

The Puget Sound transportation fuels report also projected that the maximum achievable reduction in carbon intensity in the region resulting from a similar clean fuel standard is 26 percent among transportation fuels by 2030, with an estimated 10 percent as the minimum reduction.

Rep. Kelly Chambers, R-Puyallup, urged against passage, claiming environmental benefits would not be worth the economic costs. She argued it is not equitable for the bill to make exemptions for airline companies, but then place the burdens of these regulations on industries such as agriculture.

The bill’s companion, Senate Bill 5412, is still in committee.

Cameron Sheppard is a reporter with the WNPA News Service.

More in News

BI police chief explains sexual assault protocol

Like other police departments around the country, Bainbridge Island’s is under scrutiny.… Continue reading

Health District confirms 16 new COVID-19 cases in Kitsap since yesterday

Countywide total of virus cases since pandemic began is 773

Bainbridge student wins national title in accounting

Even though he’s only a sophomore in high school, AJ JensenLopez of… Continue reading

BI council to discuss police, planning, plastic bags Tuesday

The Bainbridge Island City Council will be discussing its police department, planning… Continue reading

ESD reports another small drop in initial unemployment claims in Kitsap

Initial unemployment claims in Kitsap County continued to decline for a third… Continue reading

7th Kitsap County resident dies of COVID-19

Positive test rate over the last 30 days is nearly 6 percent

Inslee says schools in virus hot spots should stay closed

OLYMPIA — Gov. Jay Inslee doesn’t want schools in the state’s coronavirus… Continue reading

Bainbridge Island Race Equity Task Force wants to pick its members

Members of the Bainbridge Island Race Equity Task Force at a recent… Continue reading

Inslee sets rules to open up care facilities

Gov. Jay Inslee and officials from the state Department of Health and… Continue reading

Most Read