Charges filed in McKinstry slaying

The counselor’s son was expected to enter a plea of not guilty Tuesday. Kitsap County pros­ecutors charged Gar­rett L. Mc­Kin­stry with second de­gree mur­der Friday, for the stab­bing death of his father and Ord­way Elemen­tary School counselor Jeffrey McKinstry at his home last week. Garrett McKinstry’s arraignment was scheduled for 3 p.m. Tuesday, but his attorney, David LaCross of Port Orchard, said his client would be sent to Western State Hospital for a determination of his mental competency before he enters a plea to the court.

  • Wednesday, October 17, 2007 5:00pm
  • News

A memorial for Jeff McKinstry at the Ordway School sign.

The counselor’s son was expected to enter a plea of not guilty Tuesday.

Kitsap County pros­ecutors charged Gar­rett L. Mc­Kin­stry with second de­gree mur­der Friday, for the stab­bing death of his father and Ord­way Elemen­tary School counselor Jeffrey McKinstry at his home last week.

Garrett McKinstry’s arraignment was scheduled for 3 p.m. Tuesday, but his attorney, David LaCross of Port Orchard, said his client would be sent to Western State Hospital for a determination of his mental competency before he enters a plea to the court.

Garrett McKinstry, 21, had no prior felony convictions in Kitsap County but did have a reckless driving conviction on his record from earlier this year, prosecutors said.

Hull would not comment on what motivated the stabbing, which prosecutors say Garrett McKinstry admitted to investigators at the scene.

“We do know this individual stabbed his father on numerous occasions,” Hull said. “In terms of the circumstances surrounding this case, it’s still under investigation and I can’t speak to that at this point.”

Scott Wilson of the Kitsap County Sheriff’s Department said that officers had recently tried to contact Garrett McKinstry about his involvement in a reported shoving match at a pub, but the young man was never reached for questioning and the case was forwarded to the prosecutor’s office. Hull said no charges had been filed in that case.

Sheriff’s deputies found Jeffrey McKinstry, 53, dead in the driveway of his Kingston home on the evening of Oct. 11, after responding to a 911 call reporting a domestic dispute.

Garrett McKinstry was arrested at the scene. He allegedly told prosecutors that his father had told him to move out of the house after getting home from work that day, and that he had stabbed his father about 20 times with a kitchen knife, then tried to light the body on fire with gasoline in the driveway.

News of Jeff McKinstry’s death spread quickly on Bainbridge after his identity was released Friday morning.

By Friday evening a pile of flowers and cards had appeared at the base of the Ordway Elementary School sign on Madison Avenue as an impromptu memorial.

“That’s how kids knew him, just like that,” one mourner told his daughter Friday, gesturing to a black and white photo of McKinstry grinning broadly. “He was there at the doorway every morning to greet them.”

The Ordway Parent Teacher Organization will host a twilight vigil for McKinstry in the Ordway yard at 6:30 p.m. Oct. 17.

A memorial service for McKinstry is planned for 2 p.m. Oct. 20 at Woodward Middle School.

More in News

Gas buyback or electric subsidy could be in your future

Bainbridge City Councilmember Rasham Nassar is so serious about reducing gas emissions… Continue reading

Council makes changes to proposed BI budget

City staff discussed with the Bainbridge Island City Council last week impacts… Continue reading

Kol Medina
Ethics complaints filed against outgoing BI council member

Councilmember Kol Medina is leaving Bainbridge Island, but not without controversy. The… Continue reading

Local officials downplay sex ed vote controversy

Editor’s note: Some terms used in this story may be offensive to… Continue reading

.
Quarantine O’Ween an option to supplement trick-or-treating

Virtual variety show being put on by nonprofit Vitalize Kitsap

Blank Unemployment Benefits formq
Unemployment fell in Kitsap County to 6.8 percent in September

Kitsap County had one of the lowest rates of unemployment in Western… Continue reading

The Morales farmhouse after it was remodeled by Friends of the Farm in 2012. Review file photo
Council hears about farm’s affordable housing project

3 affordable housing structures would be built at city-owned Morales property

Janice Danielson and Isabelle Cobb are helping out farmers in need after the fires in Eastern Washington. Courtesy photo
Locals help with pet, livestock supplies for E. Wash. farmers

A local company is helping farmers with pets and livestock in Eastern… Continue reading

Most Read