Charges filed in McKinstry slaying

The counselor’s son was expected to enter a plea of not guilty Tuesday. Kitsap County pros­ecutors charged Gar­rett L. Mc­Kin­stry with second de­gree mur­der Friday, for the stab­bing death of his father and Ord­way Elemen­tary School counselor Jeffrey McKinstry at his home last week. Garrett McKinstry’s arraignment was scheduled for 3 p.m. Tuesday, but his attorney, David LaCross of Port Orchard, said his client would be sent to Western State Hospital for a determination of his mental competency before he enters a plea to the court.

  • Wednesday, October 17, 2007 5:00pm
  • News
A memorial for Jeff McKinstry at the Ordway School sign.

A memorial for Jeff McKinstry at the Ordway School sign.

The counselor’s son was expected to enter a plea of not guilty Tuesday.

Kitsap County pros­ecutors charged Gar­rett L. Mc­Kin­stry with second de­gree mur­der Friday, for the stab­bing death of his father and Ord­way Elemen­tary School counselor Jeffrey McKinstry at his home last week.

Garrett McKinstry’s arraignment was scheduled for 3 p.m. Tuesday, but his attorney, David LaCross of Port Orchard, said his client would be sent to Western State Hospital for a determination of his mental competency before he enters a plea to the court.

Garrett McKinstry, 21, had no prior felony convictions in Kitsap County but did have a reckless driving conviction on his record from earlier this year, prosecutors said.

Hull would not comment on what motivated the stabbing, which prosecutors say Garrett McKinstry admitted to investigators at the scene.

“We do know this individual stabbed his father on numerous occasions,” Hull said. “In terms of the circumstances surrounding this case, it’s still under investigation and I can’t speak to that at this point.”

Scott Wilson of the Kitsap County Sheriff’s Department said that officers had recently tried to contact Garrett McKinstry about his involvement in a reported shoving match at a pub, but the young man was never reached for questioning and the case was forwarded to the prosecutor’s office. Hull said no charges had been filed in that case.

Sheriff’s deputies found Jeffrey McKinstry, 53, dead in the driveway of his Kingston home on the evening of Oct. 11, after responding to a 911 call reporting a domestic dispute.

Garrett McKinstry was arrested at the scene. He allegedly told prosecutors that his father had told him to move out of the house after getting home from work that day, and that he had stabbed his father about 20 times with a kitchen knife, then tried to light the body on fire with gasoline in the driveway.

News of Jeff McKinstry’s death spread quickly on Bainbridge after his identity was released Friday morning.

By Friday evening a pile of flowers and cards had appeared at the base of the Ordway Elementary School sign on Madison Avenue as an impromptu memorial.

“That’s how kids knew him, just like that,” one mourner told his daughter Friday, gesturing to a black and white photo of McKinstry grinning broadly. “He was there at the doorway every morning to greet them.”

The Ordway Parent Teacher Organization will host a twilight vigil for McKinstry in the Ordway yard at 6:30 p.m. Oct. 17.

A memorial service for McKinstry is planned for 2 p.m. Oct. 20 at Woodward Middle School.

More in News

BI wants ferry service restored

Bainbridge Island wants its ferry system back. The city is sending a… Continue reading

.
Halloween events in BI

Four Halloween events are taking place on Bainbridge Island as the spooky… Continue reading

The current skate park is for those with advanced abilities. File Photo
BI park prepares for major remodel

Also, COVID vax for all parks users?

The Bainbridge Island City Council will have a public meeting to decide on improvements on Eagle Harbor Drive. This idea was shot down because of how crowded it would be with cyclists and walkers on the same side going in different directions.
Environment not as important on this project

Safety concerns override that on Eagle Harbor plan

.
It’s a gamble not getting COVID vaccine

Many people still are not get vaccinated to protect themselves and others… Continue reading

Eldon Van Liere stands next to his late wife's painting of Luxembourg Gardens in Paris, where they often traveled together. Tyler Shuey/Bainbridge Island Review
BI artist’s work lives on after her passing

Bainbridge Island artist Elizabeth Van Liere passed away in 2020 and some… Continue reading

The author of this book will be in Bainbridge. Courtesy Photo
Bainbridge Island briefs

Protest exhibit The Bainbridge Island Historical Museum is opening a new exhibit… Continue reading

Roundabouts on Highway 305 divided the Bainbridge Island City Council candidates at a recent debate. Courtesy Illustration
LWV’s debate features rapid-fire answers

Compared with two earlier debates last week, Bainbridge Island City Council candidates… Continue reading

Most Read