Breaking down the ballot: Our analysis of the Bainbridge council races so far

The Kitsap County Elections Division announced a new vote tally late Wednesday for the 2019 General Election.

Here’s our takeaways from a breakdown of the ballots. Results, of course, will change as more ballots are counted, and the vote tallies are not official until validated by the Kitsap County Auditor’s Office.

The big news out of Wednesday was the turnaround in the Central Ward, District 2 race, where incumbent Councilwoman Leslie Schneider squashed challenger Grayson William Wildsmith’s Election Night lead.

Schneider, who was trailing by 61 votes in the initial count, moved in front by 186 votes. That’s a 247-vote swing from the first vote tally.

An analysis of the new vote totals shows that late-arriving votes broke in Schneider’s favor by 62.2 percent — the biggest percentage gain by any Bainbridge council candidate in Wednesday’s vote tally.

In two of three council races featuring incumbents, late-arriving votes broke in favor of the incumbents.

The exception? The Michael Pollock-Sarah Blossom matchup in the South Ward.

In fact, the next biggest gain Wednesday, percentage-wise, went to Pollock, who has beaten Blossom, the incumbent, for the Position 6 seat.

Pollock pulled in 60.6 percent of all new ballots tallied Wednesday.

According to current totals, the marquee local race on the 2019 General Election ballot for Bainbridge voters was the North Ward matchup between incumbent Councilman Kol Medina and challenger Kevin Fetterly.

More Bainbridge voters cast ballots in that race than any other race, including those for the fire district, school board and park district.

A total of 5,923 ballots have been counted so far in the North Ward race.

Next biggest local race Tuesday: the at-large council matchup between Kirsten Hytopoulos and Anthony Oddo, with 5,902 ballots counted so far.

Of council races, the Central Ward race received the least amount of attention from Bainbridge voters, with 5,669 ballots cast so far. (That’s 254 fewer votes received than the North Ward contest.)

Down-ballot races got even less love from Bainbridge voters; 5,349 ballots have been counted so far in the contested park district race for Position 3; a total of 4,978 for the contested Bainbridge school board seat; and 4,935 in the contested fire board race.

Pollock said after Tuesday’s vote his campaign was grassroots-based.

The numbers back him up.

Pollock received more votes than any other Bainbridge candidate through Wednesday’s update: 3,316 votes.

Races by total number of votes

North Ward: 5,923

At-large: 5,902

South Ward: 5,769

Central Ward: 5,669

Vote gains in the second day of counting


Anthony Oddo added 509 votes to total.

Kirsten Hytopoulos picked up 567 more votes.

New ballots counted Wednesday in race: 1,076.

North Ward

Kol Medina picked up 564 votes.

Kevin Fetterly collected 608 votes.

New ballots counted Wednesday in race: 1,073.

Central Ward

Leslie Schneider added 640 votes.

Grayson William Wildsmith picked up 393 votes.

New ballots counted Wednesday in race: 1,038.

South Ward

Sarah Blossom added 408 votes.

Michael Pollock picked up 632 votes.

New ballots counted Wednesday in race: 1,042.

Percentage of new vote gain in second day of counting


Oddo pulled in 47.3 percent of Wednesday’s new total.

Hytopoulos won 52.6 percent of new votes added to total.

North Ward

Medina won 52.5 percent of additional ballots counted Wednesday.

Fetterly took 47.3 percent of new votes.

Central Ward

Schneider had 62.2 percent of Wednesday’s new total.

Wildsmith got 38.2 percent of new votes added to total.

South Ward

Blossom pulled in 39.1 percent of ballots counted Wednesday.

Pollock won 60.6 percent of all new ballots tallied.

Bainbridge council power ranking

(Based on total number of votes received)

Pollock: 3,316

Medina: 3,207

Hytopoulos: 3,115

Schneider: 2,898

Oddo: 2,772

Wildsmith: 2,712

Fetterly: 2,705

Blossom: 2,438

Races by total number of votes

North Ward: 5,923

At-large: 5,902

South Ward: 5,769

Central Ward: 5,669

More in News

Health District reports one new case of COVID-19, brings total to 164

Kitsap County positive test rate is about two percent

State increases testing efforts at long term care facilities

The state is putting together an effort to test thousands of staffers… Continue reading

Unemployment claims fall statewide as officials tout fraud prevention measures

Initial unemployment claims fell sharply both in Washington and Kitsap County during… Continue reading

Call for Justice protests scheduled for Poulsbo and Bainbridge

Protests will occur in Poulsbo on Tuesday and Bainbridge on Thursday

Protestors rally in Winslow in wake of Minneapolis killing

A rally was held at the intersection of Highway 305 and Winslow… Continue reading

Kitsap County elected officials denounce Floyd’s death in letter

An Open Letter to the Community: At the same time we are… Continue reading

Local NAACP leader calls on law enforcement to ban knee holds

Peaceful protests and demonstrations along with rioting and looting are taking place… Continue reading

Island fire department’s upgrades earn improved ranking from state bureau

Bainbridge Island is measurably safer these days and that could soon save… Continue reading

Coroner asks public for help with unclaimed remains

Kitsap County Coroner Jeff Wallis announced his office is in possession of… Continue reading

Most Read