The Photo with Borderline Truth | Peter Funt

The little girl at the border with tears in her eyes. We saw her on front pages, on TV newscasts and on the cover of Time magazine.

It’s a powerful image — perhaps more responsible than anything else for forcing a change in the administration’s policy on separating kids from parents in immigration cases.

Yet, as we learned a few days later, this particular child was never separated from her mother. At the moment the photo was taken, the mother was being frisked by border agents, a fairly routine process that took roughly two minutes.

Does it matter? That’s a question prompting robust debate among journalists as well as fierce pushback from the White House.

The photographer, veteran John Moore of Getty Images, never suggested that the young Honduran girl was being separated from her parent. Moore called the photo “a straightforward and honest image” showing a “distressed little girl” whose mother was being searched.

However, the flood of emotion and outrage that swept across the nation was clearly not about searches. It was about separation. And Moore’s photo quickly became an icon in protests about the later.

The picture was used by a California couple who set up a fundraiser on Facebook. Over a half-million people have contributed, and the fund has exceeded $20 million.

The New York Daily News ran the photo as its entire front page. A tiny caption stated that the girl’s mother was being searched, but the clear implication was that this was a case of separation. Indeed, the paper’s accompanying headline spoke of “children ripped from parents at border.”

News photos play an important role in selling a story — and a point of view — because photos never lie. Or do they?

Consider the quickly-viral photo of President Trump and German Chancellor Angela Merkel, seemingly locked in a stare-down at the Group of Seven gathering. Mr. Trump tweeted that it was a neutral moment, but many editors used the image to accompany reports of a contentious meeting.

Perhaps editors felt the photo truly reflected both a moment in time as well as the bigger picture. But what about the girl at the border? Is it journalistically responsible to use an image to represent something that it clearly is not?

The administration and conservative commentators have pounced on John Moore’s photo to criticize media and promote the notion that if this photo was misleading then perhaps the entire immigration coverage is too.

That’s not the case. But editors and advocates did themselves no favor by allowing the image to illustrate a broad position rather than a specific fact.

Moore told the Washington Post: “I believe this image has raised awareness to the zero-tolerance policy of this administration.” He added that “this photograph for me is part of a much larger story.”

Perhaps. But ends-justify-the-means coverage is not good journalism.

The notion that a picture is worth a thousand words is of no use if those words must be devoted to clarifying what the picture is really about.

Peter Funt is a writer and speaker.

More in Opinion

The Mighty Pen Strikes Out | Peter Funt

His portfolio of editorial cartoons in hand, Burris Jenkins Jr. arrived for… Continue reading

Fighting climate change means ending war | Robert C. Koehler

“The easy movement of high ranking military officers into jobs with major… Continue reading

Today’s cartoon for Sunday, July 21

Today’s cartoon is by Luojie, China Daily, China.… Continue reading

Republicans are Complicit in Trump’s Racism | John L. Micek

The next time a Republican tries to tell you that he or… Continue reading

‘Full Faith’ For Now | The Petri Dish

The men and women responsible for running elections in Washington’s 39 counties… Continue reading

Apollo 11 Golden Anniversary: Something for Everyone? | Tyrades!

I feared that the upcoming 50th anniversary of the first manned moon… Continue reading

Today’s cartoon for Saturday, July 20

Today’s cartoon is by Rick McKee, The Augusta Chronicle.… Continue reading

Shameless | Tom H. Hastings

Trump rally participants chanted about Ilhan Omar: “Send her back! Send her… Continue reading

Trump’s Racist Tweets: A Foretaste of Toxic 2020 | Dick Polman

White racism was at the root of Donald Trump’s 2016 candidacy, and… Continue reading

Most Read