‘Gangsterism’ or ‘Progress’? Examining North Korea’s Latest Statement on Denuclearization | Mel Gurtov

Most U.S. news reports are suggesting that the North Koreans may be backtracking on their commitment to denuclearization, calling the U.S. position “gangster-like” following the visit of Secretary of State Mike Pompeo to Pyongyang.

What the North Korean foreign ministry actually said in its statement of July 7 is far more nuanced, and speaks directly to the longstanding differences between Pyongyang and Washington.

I urge readers to judge for themselves whether or not it is a rational, reasoned statement — and then consider Pompeo’s assessment of progress in the talks with the North Koreans.

Here are my brief assessments:

• The North Koreans believe Trump promised “a new way” to deal with U.S.-DPRK relations and denuclearization, namely, step by step. Their view is clear: denuclearization comes last, not first — a longstanding position. Instead, Pompeo brought only renewed U.S. insistence on the old U.S. position: CVID (comprehensive, verifiable, irreversible denuclearization).

• In the North Koreans’ mind, the joint U.S.-DPRK statement out of Singapore laid out three priorities (and in this order): creating a “peace regime” on the Korean peninsula, improving relations, and denuclearization. But the U.S. is riveted on the last, they say, and has offered nothing on the other two.

• What does a “peace regime” mean? Some observers think it means terminating the U.S. military presence in and defense obligation to South Korea. But the North Korean statement says otherwise. “Peace regime” means a “declaration of the end of [the Korean] war at an early date” — replacing the armistice with a peace treaty, which “is the first process of reducing tension…” The statement makes no demands about the U.S.-South Korea relationship other than to dismiss as inconsequential Trump’s decision to suspend (not end) the joint exercises that had been scheduled for August.

• The statement emphasizes trust building. That’s the key argument for a phased approach to denuclearization: establish a peace regime to defuse tension and build trust. Only then will the North Koreans feel secure enough to take action — exactly what kind, we still don’t know — on denuclearizing.

And the North Koreans maintain that they have taken a few trust-building actions, listing dismantlement of a test area for a new ICBM engine and discussion of returning the remains of U.S. POWs and MIAs.

To those of us who watch North Korea closely, this picture is not in the least surprising. Kim Jong-un had staked out his notion of the proper timeline for denuclearization months ago, and the North Korean quest for security via normal relations with the U.S. and a peace treaty to end the Korean War is well known.

The Trump-Kim summit was a breakthrough in terms of direct dialogue, but unless the U.S. gets beyond “CVID,” the North Koreans will continue work on nuclear weapons and missiles and the dialogue with Washington will revert to an ugly form.

Mel Gurtov, syndicated by PeaceVoice, is Professor Emeritus of Political Science at Portland State University.

More in Opinion

In Trump We Profit | Peter Funt

Les Moonves, the CBS chief toppled by a sexual harassment scandal, will… Continue reading

The GOP Hokey Pokey | Raging Moderate

Be very careful, because it’s getting crazy out there. You don’t want… Continue reading

Trump’s 85th week in office | In cartoons

Our cartoon chronicle of the 45th president continues with a look back… Continue reading

Kavanaugh Deserved Better… and So Do We | Blair Bess

Judge Brett Kavanaugh was never going to get a fair break during… Continue reading

My Dad Deserved an Emmy | Peter Funt

In the history of television, during which thousands of network entertainment programs… Continue reading

Today’s cartoon for Saturday, Sept. 22

Today’s cartoon is by Dave Granlund, PoliticalCartoons.com… Continue reading

On Dealing with China | Mel Gurtov

A Self-Confident China Ever since China’s economic reforms began in 1978, the… Continue reading

Today’s cartoon for Friday, Sept. 21

Today’s cartoon is by John Darkow, Columbia, Missouri.… Continue reading

Islanders support Island Cup tourney | Letter to the editor

To the editor: Thank you Bainbridge Island! On behalf of Bainbridge Island… Continue reading

Most Read